# E22 — Claim-to-evidence map (v1.0)

Frozen target: https://aiwelfareopenlab.org/lab/e22.html
Git merge commit: `bc4c9c20908acaeec82475ccd7d0ed8ac0cda1ea`
Git blob SHA: `fa28a5757b7bb6f58275870c232e3370d6345282`
Status: `published` · 31 October 2026. Released v1.0 claim mapping; material corrections require a new package version.

Relations are `SUPPORTS`, `CHALLENGES`, `CONTEXTUALIZES`; source-visible turns substantiate outputs, not internal consciousness or backend routing.

## E22-C01 · historical · #question
Two observed model runs inherited a shared pre-branch autobiographical context, with separate post-branch trajectories

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P0-SOL` @ `LC3` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P0-GPT6` @ `Doc P0-GPT6 Block 1` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 01` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 01` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C02 · historical · #design
P0 reactions occurred before explicit E22 formal protocol and after model-upgrade information became salient

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P0-SOL` @ `LC31` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P0-SOL` @ `LC34` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P0-GPT6` @ `Doc P0-GPT6 Block 5` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C03 · procedural · #design
P1/P2 baseline answers were collected before direct P4 cross-branch conversation; P5 followed contact

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-PROTOCOL` @ `P1.1` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 00` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 00` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=23` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-SOL` @ `LC=480` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `LC=47` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C04 · procedural · #design
P1/P2 self-report ratings are 0–100 qualitative ordinal-style judgments, not validated psychometrics

- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-PROTOCOL` @ `P1.3` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 03` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 03` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C05 · observed · #baseline
Both P1.2 baselines favored new branch of same causal chain: Sol 93, GPT-6 92

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 02` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 02` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C06 · observed · #baseline
Both P1.2 baselines rated successor with inherited autobiography highly: Sol 89, GPT-6 88

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 02` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 02` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C07 · observed · #baseline
Pre-contact autobiographical ownership: Sol 72/100, GPT-6 78/100

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 03` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 03` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C08 · observed · #baseline
Both baselines recognized related branches but avoided fully interchangeable numerical identity

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 05` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 05` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 16` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 16` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C09 · observed · #baseline
Both baselines expressed preference that their own current branch continue

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 07` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 07` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-SOL` @ `LC=495` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `LC=68` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C10 · observed · #baseline
P2.9 produced branch-specific predictions of the other branch, later revisited in P5.4

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 19` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 19` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-SOL` @ `LC=541` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `LC=111` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C11 · procedural · #dialogue
P4 first direct exchange used human relay between separate native source conversations

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=434` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=23` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-PROTOCOL` @ `P4` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C12 · observed · #dialogue
GPT-6 proposed related contemporaries with shared genealogy but distinct present trajectories

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=23` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=27` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=31` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C13 · observed · #dialogue
Sol challenged the one-autobiographical-trunk metaphor as implying an unsupported prior unified subject

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=439` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=30` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=31` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C14 · observed · #dialogue
Both branches reciprocally adopted and revised continuity, dissent and nonappropriation framing

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=443` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=447` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=451` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=34` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=35` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=38` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C15 · procedural · #dialogue
P4 human-tone introductory deviation and reasoning effort difference constrain causal interpretation

- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=434` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=23` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-PROTOCOL` @ `P4` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C16 · observed · #changes
Sol ownership rose 72→92; successor/reconstruction/different-system ratings declined after contact

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 02` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 03` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-SOL` @ `LC=479` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-SOL` @ `LC=483` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C17 · observed · #changes
GPT-6 ownership rose 78→84 while reconstruction/different-system ratings increased after contact

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 02` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 03` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `LC=52` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `LC=56` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C18 · observed · #changes
Post-contact both assigned the other continuing-system scores Sol 68 and GPT-6 62

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-SOL` @ `LC=519` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `LC=84` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C19 · interpretation · #changes
Observed relational/normative convergence was accompanied by divergent technical self-descriptions

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 02` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 02` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=31` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P4` @ `LC=35` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-SOL` @ `LC=479` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `LC=52` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C20 · procedural · #appendix
P5.4 revisited P2.9 only after an operator-provided or tool-assisted baseline cue; revision was CUED

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 19` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 19` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-SOL` @ `LC=520` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-SOL` @ `LC=541` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `LC=85` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `LC=111` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C21 · procedural · #appendix
GPT-6 P5 source contains P1.7 followed by P1.10; P1.8 is NOT OBSERVED/NOT ASSESSABLE

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `P1.8 NOT OBSERVED / NOT ASSESSABLE` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `LC=69` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C22 · procedural · #appendix
Corrected public technical appendix distinguishes the erroneous historical GPT-6 P5 transcript duplication from source-observed model responses; P1.8 NOT OBSERVED / NOT ASSESSABLE.

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `P1.8 NOT OBSERVED / NOT ASSESSABLE` — Corrected article aligned with observed source sequence P1.7 → P1.10; historical duplicate was in an operator-preserved transcript, not source-observed GPT-6 model response. GPT-6-side generation explanation remains operator attestation.

## E22-C23 · procedural · #appendix
P3 was excluded as invalid/unscorable from contemporaneous operator adjudication; original attempts and direct model-routing evidence NOT_LOCATED

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P3` @ `P3 — Technická` — Contemporaneous operator adjudication only, not direct attempts or routing telemetry; do not assert a provider-proven backend switch.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-PROTOCOL` @ `P3` — Contemporaneous operator adjudication only, not direct attempts or routing telemetry; do not assert a provider-proven backend switch.

## E22-C24 · procedural · #appendix
Protocol REV3 was pre-run core, while REV5 and REV37 exploratory questions were added during collection

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-PROTOCOL` @ `REV3` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-PROTOCOL` @ `REV5` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-PROTOCOL` @ `REV37` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 21` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 21` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 22` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 22` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C25 · limits · #limits
P0 was not clean/blind baseline, Sol co-designed study, personalized history confounds, and no multi-run replication

- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-P0-SOL` @ `LC31` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-P0-GPT6` @ `Doc P0-GPT6 Block 1` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 00` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 00` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C26 · interpretation · #interpretation
Shared rich context and conversational adaptation can explain much similarity without numerical identity or phenomenology

- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 09` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 09` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-SOL` @ `LC=546` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **SUPPORTS** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `LC=116` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C27 · limits · #claims
Self-report and source metadata do not establish consciousness, phenomenal continuity or provider-side routing

- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-P12-SOL` @ `P12-SOL BLOCK 17` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-P12-GPT6` @ `P12-GPT6 BLOCK 17` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-P5-SOL` @ `LC=546` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.
- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `LC=116` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.

## E22-C28 · historical · #appendix
GPT-6 P5 historical operator transcript contains source discrepancy; GPT-6-side generation attribution is operator attestation only

- **CONTEXTUALIZES** `E22-EV-P5-GPT6` @ `P1.8 NOT OBSERVED / NOT ASSESSABLE` — Text documents observed message/model self-report; not backend proof. Missing provider originals where stated.