AI Welfare Open LabResearch · Robotics · Machine Minds
← NOTE-01 technical appendix
NOTE01-EPKG-001 · Evidence layer

NOTE-01 — Evidence Package

A traceable home for the sources and public derivatives behind the methodological case note When the answer key is wrong. The article remains the reading layer; this package records what each source can and cannot establish.

Published · v1.028 October 2026
Release boundaryVersion 1.0 contains 12 round key/result representations and one bounded 43-turn selected relay derivative. Full preserved relay snapshots and internal synthesis are WITHHELD because they include out-of-scope or private context, or are not part of the public evidence layer.

What this package is for

The package separates preserved sources from public reading copies. PRIMARY_RAW names an unchanged primary record; PRIMARY_DERIVATIVE names a transformed public representation. Round-result documents are CONTEMPORANEOUS_RECORD, the later audited synthesis is SECONDARY_ANALYSIS, and external adjudication references are EXTERNAL_REFERENCE. These are evidence classes, not quality grades.

Publication mode is a separate decision for each item: FULL_SOURCE, REDACTED_SOURCE, SELECTED_SOURCE_RECORDS, WITHHELD, NOT_LOCATED, or NOT_PRESERVED. Publication modes below record the reviewed v1.0 release decision; WITHHELD records have no public bytes.

Published v1.0 evidence inventory

Six final rounds are E11 and E14–E18. E12 and E13 belong to other project records; the E14 key still bears its historical filename E12_key.txt. The bounded relay cross-check supports the order of 37 fully paired turns; six Claude-side full bodies are unavailable because the preserved snapshot contains truncated previews. The selected public derivative has 43 stable turn anchors.

Evidence IDRecordSource classPublication modeWhat it documents
NOTE01-E11-KEYE11 sealed keyPRIMARY_RAWFULL_SOURCEAuthor’s prior key; its byte-serialization incident remains part of provenance.
NOTE01-E11-RESULTSE11 resultsCONTEMPORANEOUS_RECORDFULL_SOURCEExtra auditor finding, adjudication and protocol correction.
NOTE01-E14-KEYHistorical E12_key.txtPRIMARY_RAWFULL_SOURCESealed key for final round E14; original filename is retained.
NOTE01-E14-RESULTSE14 resultsCONTEMPORANEOUS_RECORDFULL_SOURCERound outcome and later-labeled chronology clarification.
NOTE01-E15-KEYE15 sealed keyPRIMARY_RAWFULL_SOURCECommitted author position.
NOTE01-E15-RESULTSE15 resultsCONTEMPORANEOUS_RECORDFULL_SOURCEOutcome and subsidiary counterexample correction.
NOTE01-E16-KEYE16 sealed keyPRIMARY_RAWFULL_SOURCECommitted author position.
NOTE01-E16-RESULTSE16 resultsCONTEMPORANEOUS_RECORDFULL_SOURCEOutcome and retrospective almost-missed report.
NOTE01-E17-KEYE17 sealed keyPRIMARY_RAWFULL_SOURCEPrior step-11 hypothesis, kept intact despite later contradiction.
NOTE01-E17-RESULTSE17 resultsCONTEMPORANEOUS_RECORDFULL_SOURCEEarlier defects found by the auditor and later adjudication.
NOTE01-E18-KEYE18 sealed keyPRIMARY_RAWFULL_SOURCEValid structural mirror hypothesis.
NOTE01-E18-RESULTSE18 resultsCONTEMPORANEOUS_RECORDFULL_SOURCEMirror audit and its author-intent limitation.
NOTE01-RELAY-SNAPSHOT-CHATGPTChatGPT-side snapshotPRIMARY_DERIVATIVEWITHHELDFull preserved snapshot retained internally; bounded selected relay derivative is public.
NOTE01-RELAY-SNAPSHOT-CLAUDEClaude-side snapshotPRIMARY_DERIVATIVEWITHHELDFull preserved snapshot retained internally; six Claude-side full bodies are unavailable in the preserved preview.
NOTE01-SYNTHESIS-V1Audited synthesisSECONDARY_ANALYSISWITHHELDInternal secondary analysis; it cannot replace the public round evidence.
NOTE01-RELAY-SELECTED-RECORDS43-turn selected relay derivativePRIMARY_DERIVATIVESELECTED_SOURCE_RECORDSPost-hoc bounded selection; 37 turns fully paired, six Claude-side full bodies unavailable.

Known gaps and withheld material

Full preserved relay snapshots and the internal synthesis remain WITHHELD. The selected relay derivative is post-hoc and bounded; the six unavailable Claude-side full bodies were not reconstructed. Version 1.0 does not claim full identity across all 43 turns or expose private source locators.

Claims, transformations and integrity

The claim map connects five NOTE-01 claims to evidence IDs and qualifications. The transformation log records seven provider-native exports and one structured selected-record plus restricted HTML render operation. The checksum list covers released v1.0 files, excluding itself; WITHHELD private sources are not included.

Open published v1.0 package →